The Captain Sim Paradox: Why Low-Quality Add-ons Still Sell
Hello and welcome back!
A few posts ago, I mentioned that while I hadn’t published new content in several months, I’ve remained active—answering emails and responding to reader inquiries. Some of those questions, particularly about Microsoft Flight Simulator 2024, were beyond my expertise. Others, however, I could easily address.
Just today, I received a question from Jackson about the newly released Captain Sim Boeing 717. He wanted to know my thoughts on the aircraft and whether it was worth purchasing. Jackson is new to flight simulation, with MSFS 2024 serving as his introduction to our wonderful hobby.
For long-time readers familiar with my perspective, my advice might be predictable. While I have strong opinions against Captain Sim and similar developers, I shared my thoughts candidly while encouraging Jackson to conduct his own research before spending his hard-earned money.
Over the years, many fellow enthusiasts have asked why developers like Captain Sim remain successful despite their poor reputation among hardcore simmers. The answer is rather simple: I wouldn’t be surprised if Captain Sim ranks among the highest earners in the Microsoft Flight Simulator Marketplace. Here’s why:
- Impressive Exterior Modeling – Despite their reputation and inability to create high-fidelity systems logic, their aircraft models are undeniably well-crafted. Many respected developers could benefit from a partnership where Captain Sim handles exterior modeling while leaving flight dynamics and systems to more experienced teams.
- Competitive Pricing – Captain Sim typically prices its add-ons attractively. For newcomers unaware of their history—or those uninterested in study-level aircraft—their offerings can seem appealing. That said, I strongly dislike their practice of charging for livery packs.
- New Audiences – Every new simulator release introduces a fresh audience. With MSFS 2020 and 2024 bringing flight simulation to console players, many new users remain unaware of certain developers’ past business practices. As a result, companies like Captain Sim continue to thrive.
The reality is, Captain Sim isn’t going anywhere anytime soon. Developers like them will persist, creating add-ons that—at least for those of us who care about authenticity—are as useless as a chocolate teapot. New simmers will continue to buy them, and the most we can do is educate and inform newcomers.
Until next time,
Happy flying!
—Jerry
